Monday, March 5, 2012

"If the literature we are reading does not wake us, why do we read it? A literary work must be an ice-axe to break the sea frozen inside us."

---Franz Kafka
(adapted)


What does this quote mean? Provide a valid interpretation of this statement, agree or disagree with the statement as you have interpreted it, and support your opinion using specific references. Don't forget to comment on someone else's opinion.

26 comments:

Shawn Alexis said...

This quote is saying that if you don't like the book, why read it. Like once during the summer my mom was telling me to read a lord of the rings book and from the first 2 pages I knew I wasn't going to like it so I just read Maniac Magee. There are no comments me to comment on.

TeeTee James said...

This quote mean if you don't like a book why would you read it. The book should be intersecting to you in order for you to enjoy that book. Yesterday my friend gave me a book called "To BE Together" just by looking at it I knew I wasn't going to read it. I agree with Shawn Alexis because I think what he said is mostly what the quote is saying.

~!Toni JAmes!~

Kanye West - Good Life ft. T-Pain said...

I think that the quote means that if a certain book doesn't entertain or interest us in any way , there would be no reason or challenge to read it .For instance when my cousin told me to try and read the Alex Ride series, I tried to because it sounded interesting.However , as soon as I had read the first five pages, I felt boredom wash over me like the sea does at the beach .I agree with Shawn Alexis and Toni James because they both seem to understand the concept of the quote , and can do a text-to-me connection.

Kanye West - Good Life ft. T-Pain said...

ISIAH METELLUS 271

Kinetic Kid33 said...

This quote means that if a book isn’t fit for us we should conclude that it may bore us and it won’t get the reader’s attention. The book should help us with things so we can refer to it. Also, it should be enjoyable to read so we can read it more to let our brain be active. Once, I read a book called “Parzival” and by reading the foreword I knew it was going to be useless. I did not enjoy it but still had to read it for class. The storyline was so erratic. I disagree with Toni because you can’t judge a book by a cover. I agree with her because some books aren’t our type.

Joshua Nelson 271

Anime said...

This quote means if you dont like literature why should we listen to it, why should we read it.The book\article is surpose to get us excited not make us frozen and bored. I say this because there is this book i really really wanted to read (Rock Between A, Hard Place) and i got this book called Separte but Not Equal and it look boring. But when i read it it made me frozen and bored. the other people reading that book didnt want to read it. This story supports my topic because the separte book couldnt break my ice was to hard to break. i kinda disagree with Joshua because sometimes you can judge a book my its cover. the book i saw the cover looked boring and wshen i read it, it was boring

Anime said...

Ch!N!R@ Wh!Tn3y

Mr.Lewis said...

This quote is saying that if we don't like a book why read it because if we read something that doesn't excite us why read it.This boring book is not going to benefit you or leave you with a new state of mind.

aquia parris said...

i think this quote means that if a book dosent interest you why bother to stay on it.. in order for you to be amazed you have to find a book to wake you for you to see what good it is inside. i agree with everyone expect Joshua because yes you can judge a book by its cover also it really dosent matter cause it can be good or bad so basically its 50-50 chance of facing a good book that may interest you than one that is a bore.so in all don't read a book that don't excite you because it wouldn't wake you it will just sit there and nothing will come to mind.its like what all parents or teachers say "when ever they speech it goes straight out the other ear." because when you read its like no information about the book is going through your mind its going rite out the door. so always read a book that may break the sea in us so we can explore what we are reading.
*AQUIA PARRIS*
*271*

Unknown said...

I think this quote means that if a book don't stand out to us, why read it? I agree with this quote because i only read books that are interesting to me. I agree with Aquia Parris' post because that covers all that the quote means

ARIANA HOLNESS said...

I think this quote not only relates to reading a book but also everyday life not everything we do in life is going to be intresting but we have to do them as a part of gaining knowledge over a period of time as the quote states why read a book if it does not wake us reading maketh a man and the more one read then u will be aware of your local knowledge and current affairs.I have to disagree with the statement because not everything a person read is going to be interesting but in life we are given tasks especially in schools that must be met whether we like reading a book that wakes us up.ARIANA HOLNESS
CLASS 271*

Giqqless : ) said...

The reason why we read it even though it doesnt awaken us is because it can entertain us in many things even though its not doing anything for us. I disagree with Joshua Nelson Because you can so judge a book by its cover because i do it all the time and i literally mean a book .
Iniah Benjamin 271

MeganeN said...

In my interpratation, this quote means:
"If our principle of laws does not give us understanding, then why do we have it? A literary work has to be a hidden knowledge that we have."
I agree wuth this statement and with Ariana Holness because she truly understands the quote and gives a clear statement of her beliefs. I say that because, in life, when I don't understand emotions such as poetry, I seek to find its true meaning, and maybe even sometimes relate to it.
Megane Nacier. Class 282

terry said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
terry said...

i think this quote is saying that if you dont like a book why read it or if you dont understand the book why would you read it. im not saying that you cant try but if you are really trying to read it and you still dont get it just give up because you already know its not in your level so you know just give it up. my mother gave me this book with like 800 pages, by looking at it i know that its not my level and it looks really boring.

terry said...

terry denis 282

Tia Mckay said...

This quote means if you dont like a book and dont want to read it why should you read it.Like the time when i was sick my aunt got me a book called "Life is like hell". I could already see I wasnt going to read it.I already know life is like hell but in a good and bad way.So i would agree with TeeTee James in what she said about the quote and what it means.

zack said...

I think the quote means if u don't like a book then don't waste your time to read it. One time my friends told me to read a book they found interesting called Percy Jackson and the Lightling Theif, when i started reading the book i did not find anything interesting about it.

Zachary gibbs
Class 271

Simone Aiken said...

I think the quote means that why would you be wasting your time on a book you do not like. For a book to be interesting it must pull you into the story. Once I was given a book called "House" to read which a lot of people found it appealing. When I started to read it I never understand what was great about it. Even on the first page there was nothing to keep me reading. I disagree with the statement because you don't have to keep reading something you don't enjoy. I agree with Tia McKay because her point was making sense about the quote meaning.

Simone Aiken 271

Liqhtt Skinnz said...

this quote means that if the book you are reading is boring than why do you still read it. you should read a book that grabs your attention and something you can relate to.
Fiona larmond 282

Lauryn C. said...

I think this quote means if you have a book and your not enjoying it why bother to continue reading it, its a waste of time. In elementary I was taught that in order to find a good book it should have all the things that you are looking for in a book. Why bother reading a book you do not like, it will be like someone is forcing you to read it.

Lauryn Clarke, Class 271

cynthia elinor said...

This quote mean if you don't like a book why would you read it , or if u know it don't look interesting do not read it.i agree with lenworth Lewis because he is right a boring book wont benefit you or leave you with a new state of mind in any way.
cynthia elinor
class: 282

spouney paul said...

This quote is saying that we do we read what read but dont like it its because it touches into your mind and which gives you a clear vision what your reading but yet you dont understand and see that image which makes this boring.

Spouney Paul
282

hershey said...

This quote mean if you don't like a book why would you read it.I say this because if a book not enjoyable to the read there is no point in reading the book.You need a book to show you ways to improve yourself in many ways.So I agree with this quote.

Stephanie Brown 282

jasmine said...

this quote means if u are reading a book u don't like then whats the point of of reading it to waste your time? the book u are reading u have to have some interest in it or why u reading it in the first place.u should read something u like and something u think is interesting.

jasmine said...

Jasmine Elyzee -271-